[Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines Alan Watson (12 Apr 2012 02:30 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
John Cowan
(12 Apr 2012 04:09 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
Peter Bex
(12 Apr 2012 07:49 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
Alex Queiroz
(12 Apr 2012 07:51 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
Alaric Snell-Pym
(12 Apr 2012 09:22 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
Alex Shinn
(12 Apr 2012 11:52 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
Alan Watson
(12 Apr 2012 13:02 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
Alex Shinn
(12 Apr 2012 13:46 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
Jeronimo Pellegrini
(12 Apr 2012 13:58 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
Alan Watson
(12 Apr 2012 16:08 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
Marc Feeley
(12 Apr 2012 13:09 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
Alex Shinn
(15 Apr 2012 14:32 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
John Cowan
(12 Apr 2012 13:57 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
Alex Shinn
(14 Apr 2012 01:58 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
John Cowan
(14 Apr 2012 02:41 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
Alex Shinn
(14 Apr 2012 03:00 UTC)
|
Re: [Scheme-reports] Boolean hemlines
John Cowan
(14 Apr 2012 03:08 UTC)
|
A long time ago, some people made the decision that #t/#f were in some sense better than #!true/#!false. More recently, the WG1 have made a different decision that #true/#false are in some sense better than #t/#f. This decision is not without cost. If an R7RS Scheme writes a boolean datum as #true or #false, it likely cannot be read by a R4RS, R5RS, or R6RS Scheme. It is unrealistic and probably undesirable to require perfect compatibility between iterations of Scheme, but changing the spelling a fundamental data is perhaps unexpected. The WG1 needs to decide if this cost is acceptable, and if not either revert their decision to allow #true/#false or require write to produce #t/#f. Regards, Alan _______________________________________________ Scheme-reports mailing list Scheme-reports@scheme-reports.org http://lists.scheme-reports.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/scheme-reports